I have been told that when it comes to an occupancy separation between a ambulatory health care and business occupancy that CMS requires that the one hour fire rated wall serving this purpose "must" extend to the underside of the roof deck slab/deck per 184.108.40.206. Is seems apparent to me that NFPA 101-2012, provides a clear alternative to the extension of the the wall to the roof deck per 220.127.116.11.4 and Chapter 8 which permits “fire barriers” as a means of providing a one hour fire rated occupancy separation, including both "vertical" and "horizontal" fire barrier separation per 18.104.22.168(2), between an Ambulatory Health Care and Business occupancy rather than by extension of the one-hour wall to the underside of the roof deck per 22.214.171.124?
I have been told that CMS doesn't recognize this alternative of 126.96.36.199(2) since 188.8.131.52 does not refer to the wall as a “fire barrier” nor does it reference Chapter 8. This would in effect create a more restrictive requirement (more restrictive than the requirements of a fire barrier requirements of Chapter 8) for a wall type separating an Ambulatory Health Care occupancy from an adjacent business or other occupancy with no alternative other then to extend the wall vertically to the underside of the roof.
Does anyone have first hand experience with CMS's interpretation or application of 184.108.40.206 or any instances where such a wall was indeed recognized as a fire barrier and permitted to comply with 220.127.116.11(2) as an acceptable alternative?